Free Legal Aid
  • The Torrent: 3 suits in 3 years

  • Save and organize email so e-discoverable

  • Documents can be two-edged swords

  • Lawyers aren't friends; they are advisors

  • Remember: it's about business, not being right

  • Justice is a myth

  • Play A game if attorney's fees recoverable

  • Play B or C game on defense unless case tough

  • Try to settle, but don't be stupid

  • Listen to your gut: it's your business

Notes:

For a tiny company, we've been hit pretty hard on the legal front. Not many startups receive an SEC letter or are hit with a lawsuit in their first two years.

In the last three years, we have been hit with two lawsuits for breach and had to file a complaint for non-payment. We went to the court for the latter and won with a full award (attorney's fees, costs, and interest), and are in the process of collecting (May 2010).

We settled a suit with our only competitor in one market, and that competitor was bought by our only channel partner a couple of months later. We terminated channel partner contract, but are now being sued for breach. While it may seem obvious to outsiders, the law does not exist until there is a judgement, literally. Anybody can sue anybody for anything. It may be thrown out, but it still costs real money to defend yourself.

The settlement was a mistake, which sort of knew at the time (we would have won our case), but our lawyers pressed us to settle for "certainty". While that's an important concept, you have to get in the heads of the opposing party. It's quite like poker, but the stakes are higher, and the data are thin. You don't get to see hundreds of lawsuits play out.

Use your resources wisely. Take your time. Try, try again does not apply here. Analysis and logic do.